Pabulib analysis

Pabustats

Explore how official participatory budgeting outcomes represent voters, use available budgets, and compare with alternative allocation rules.

1054 of 2015 current datasets can currently be analysed. Pabustats supports approval ballots with recorded winners.

Beta version. Pabustats is still being tested and its results may contain errors. Recorded-outcome indicators are calculated directly from each dataset's votes, project costs, budget, and selected values. Alternative allocations are computed with the maintained Pabutools rule engine, and Pabulib then derives the comparison indicators shown here. If you find an error or an unexpected result, please let us know.

Rule sensitivity

Recorded outcome vs MES + Add1

MES iterated with 1% increases of the virtual budget until the outcome is exhaustive or ceases to fit. Positive representation changes favour the alternative outcome.

Showing 13 cached comparisons from 1049 eligible datasets.

Cannot see the dataset you are interested in? Comparisons are loaded from cache, so a dataset appears here only after its result has been calculated. Select a dataset below to calculate it now.

Download this comparison as CSV
Warszawa · 2017

Poland · Sadul

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
33.3%
Official winners replaced
50.0%
Budget removed / added
49.9% / 11.6%
Representation change
+5.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
9 / 3
Avg. choices change
-0.40
Gdynia · 2022

Poland · Kamienna Góra | large

Recorded rule
greedy-no-skip
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Gdynia · 2022

Poland · Kamienna Góra | small

Recorded rule
greedy-no-skip
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Olsztyn · 2027

Poland · Brzeziny

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Olsztyn · 2027

Poland · Kętrzyńskiego

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Olsztyn · 2027

Poland · Zielona Górka

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2017

Poland · Nadwiśle

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2017

Poland · Plac Wojska Polskiego

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2018

Poland · Pole Mokotowskie

Recorded rule
greedy-threshold
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2018

Poland · Przyczółek Grochowski

Recorded rule
greedy-threshold
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2018

Poland · Sadul

Recorded rule
greedy-threshold
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2019

Poland · Marysin Wawerski Południowy

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Warszawa · 2019

Poland · Sadul

Recorded rule
greedy
Final alternative
MES + Add1
Winner similarity
100.0%
Official winners replaced
0.0%
Budget removed / added
0.0% / 0.0%
Representation change
+0.0 pp
Voters gaining / losing
0 / 0
Avg. choices change
+0.00
Open a dataset for the detailed Rule Comparison.

Open a dataset to inspect its projects and source data in Preview.